Criminal Defense

Juvenile Crime Lawyer

Juvenile Crime Lawyer | Understanding protective disposition, criminal punishment, and early diversion

Summary

In Korea, a minor who commits an offense may be routed to one of two very different systems: the juvenile protection system (protective disposition under the Juvenile Act, 소년법) or the adult criminal justice system (criminal punishment). Which track applies depends on the child's age, the severity of the act, and prior record — and the decision point often comes earlier than parents expect, at the police or prosecutor stage. Whether a case ends in a protective disposition, a criminal trial, or a conditional non-prosecution with guidance conditions can depend heavily on how the case is handled from the very first interview.

Criminal · Juvenile Related law: Juvenile Act (소년법) Parent/Guardian Perspective Related law: Act on Juvenile Justice Procedure (소년심판규칙)

Juvenile Crime | Protective Disposition vs. Criminal Punishment: How the Track Is Decided

Not every juvenile case goes to the same place. Depending on age, the nature of the offense, and the case's procedural posture, a juvenile's case can end up in family/juvenile court seeking a protective disposition, or in criminal court facing an adult-style sentence. Below is a simplified comparison of the three most common outcomes parents encounter.

Protective Disposition

Applies to juveniles under 19 whose case is referred to juvenile court for welfare-oriented measures rather than punishment

Legal nature	Not a criminal penalty; no criminal record created
Possible outcomes	Probation, community service, counseling order, or institutional commitment
Who decides	Family court or district court juvenile division
Effect on future	Generally does not appear as a criminal conviction

Governed by the Juvenile Act (소년법 제32조), which lists ten types of protective dispositions ranging from probation to commitment to a juvenile reformatory.

Criminal Prosecution

Applies when the offense is serious, the juvenile is 14 or older and deemed criminally responsible, or the prosecutor decides punishment is warranted

Legal nature	Criminal case; may result in conviction and record
Possible outcomes	Fine, suspended sentence, imprisonment (juvenile-specific limits apply)
Who decides	Criminal court (district court)
Effect on future	May create a criminal record depending on sentence type

Juveniles under 14 are not criminally responsible and cannot be criminally punished, though they may still receive a protective disposition (소년법 제4조, 형법 제9조).

Conditional Non-Prosecution

A diversion option where the prosecutor decides not to indict in exchange for the juvenile completing counseling, education, or community service

Legal nature	Case closed without prosecution or court record
Possible outcomes	Completion of guidance program ends the case
Who decides	Prosecutor, often after police referral
Effect on future	No conviction; case does not proceed to trial or juvenile court

Based on prosecutorial discretion under the Juvenile Act and internal prosecution guidelines on conditional non-prosecution with counseling/education conditions (소년법 제49조의3).

Juvenile Crime | How Age and Offense Severity Determine the Path

The single biggest factor parents ask about is: will my child go through juvenile court or a criminal trial? The answer depends on a combination of age brackets and how the police or prosecutor classify the offense.

Age brackets under the Juvenile Act

Children under 10 are outside the scope of any sanction. Those aged 10 to 13 ('victim of circumstance' or pre-criminal juveniles, 촉법소년) can only receive a protective disposition, never criminal punishment, because they lack criminal responsibility (소년법 제4조 제1항 제2호, 형법 제9조). Juveniles aged 14 to 18 can be criminally prosecuted, but many first-time or minor cases are still referred to juvenile court instead.

Referral to juvenile court by the prosecutor

For juveniles 14 or older, the prosecutor reviews the case and may choose to file criminal charges or instead refer the case to family/juvenile court for a protective disposition where punishment is judged unnecessary given the juvenile's circumstances (소년법 제49조). This referral decision is one of the most important turning points in the entire case, and it is where defense counsel's input to the prosecutor can matter most.

When the court itself can choose a protective disposition mid-trial

Even after a criminal case has been filed, a criminal court may transfer the case back to family court if it concludes a protective disposition is more appropriate than punishment (소년법 제50조). This means the door to a non-punitive outcome is not always closed once an indictment is filed.

Juvenile Crime | Conditional Non-Prosecution and Guidance Programs

For many first-time or lower-severity cases, the most favorable realistic outcome is not winning a not-guilty verdict but avoiding prosecution altogether through a conditional non-prosecution program.

What conditional non-prosecution actually requires

Under this framework, the prosecutor agrees not to indict if the juvenile completes designated conditions such as counseling sessions, an educational course, or community service, sometimes administered together with the Korean Juvenile Protection Center or affiliated organizations. Successful completion typically results in the case being closed with no indictment and no court record.

Why timing and documentation matter

Because this decision is made by the prosecutor before indictment, the window to present mitigating materials — an apology letter, evidence of restitution to the victim, counseling attendance, school records, and a parental supervision plan — is limited to the investigation stage. Once an indictment is filed, this diversion option is generally no longer available for that charge.

Interaction with victim reconciliation

In many juvenile cases (property offenses, school violence, minor assault), demonstrating that restitution or reconciliation with the victim has occurred can be a decisive factor in whether the prosecutor grants conditional non-prosecution rather than referring the case toward indictment or juvenile court commitment.

Juvenile Crime | The Guardian's Role and Legal Responsibility

Parents are not passive bystanders in these proceedings — the Juvenile Act and related procedures actively involve guardians, and a guardian's conduct can influence the disposition chosen by the court.

Guardian's duty to attend and supervise

Guardians are generally expected to appear at police and court proceedings and may be asked to submit a supervision plan describing how they will prevent reoffending. Courts weigh evidence of a stable home environment and parental engagement when selecting among the ten types of protective dispositions (소년법 제32조).

Guardian fines and civil liability considerations

Separately from the juvenile's own case, guardians may face civil liability for damages caused by their child depending on the circumstances, and in some contexts a court may order a guardian to complete parental education alongside the juvenile's protective disposition (소년법 제32조의2).

Choosing counsel early changes the options available

Because so much depends on decisions made at the police and prosecutor stage — before any court hearing — parents who consult a lawyer immediately after their child is summoned for questioning have meaningfully more options than those who wait until an indictment or court referral has already occurred. A juvenile crime lawyer can help decide which mitigating materials to submit and when.

Juvenile Crime | From Police Notice to Case Resolution

Initial consultation and case assessment
Review the police summons or complaint, the juvenile's age bracket, and the specific allegations to identify whether protective disposition, criminal prosecution, or diversion is the realistic range of outcomes.

Police investigation stage
Attend the police interview with the juvenile if permitted, prepare a written statement strategy, and begin gathering mitigating materials such as an apology letter, restitution proof, and school records.

Prosecutor review and diversion request
Submit a written opinion to the prosecutor requesting conditional non-prosecution or referral to juvenile court, supported by evidence of remorse, victim reconciliation, and a parental supervision plan.

Juvenile court hearing (if referred)
If the case moves to family/juvenile court, prepare the juvenile and guardian for the hearing, and present evidence relevant to which of the ten protective dispositions best fits the circumstances (소년법 제32조).

Criminal trial (if indicted)
If the prosecutor indicts, shift strategy toward criminal defense, including arguments for reduced sentencing given the juvenile's age and circumstances, and consider requesting the court transfer the case to juvenile court under 소년법 제50조.

Case closure and follow-up
Confirm completion of any guidance program conditions or the final disposition, and advise on record-related consequences, including sealing or non-disclosure considerations for juvenile records.

Juvenile Crime | How Fees Are Typically Structured

Consultation fee
An initial consultation may be free or charged depending on case complexity; this is clarified before any engagement begins.

Retainer fee
Calculated based on the stage at which representation begins (police stage, prosecutor stage, or after indictment) and the complexity of the allegations, rather than a flat rate.

Success-linked fee
Where permitted under attorney advertising rules, a portion of the fee may be tied to achieving a specific procedural outcome such as conditional non-prosecution or a favorable protective disposition, agreed upon in advance.

Additional stage fees
If a case escalates from police investigation to indictment, or from juvenile court to criminal court, an additional fee for the added stage is typically discussed separately.

Incidental costs
Costs such as document fees, transportation for hearings outside the firm's usual jurisdiction, and expert consultation fees (if needed) are billed separately as incurred.

※ Costs vary depending on case complexity and specific circumstances; exact fees will be provided during consultation. No specific outcome is guaranteed.

Juvenile Crime | Self-Check for Parents and Guardians

1️⃣ Right After the Police Summons

Have you confirmed whether your child is being investigated as a suspect or only as a witness?
Do you know your child's exact age bracket (under 10, 10–13, or 14–18) and why it matters?
Have you arranged for a guardian or lawyer to accompany your child at the police interview?
Have you avoided letting your child make statements to police without preparation?

2️⃣ Building the Case for Non-Prosecution

Has your child written a sincere apology letter, and has it reached the victim or their representative?
Have you attempted restitution or compensation discussions with the victim?
Has your child begun any voluntary counseling or educational program relevant to the offense?
Do you have school records or statements showing your child's overall conduct and character?

3️⃣ If the Case Is Referred to Juvenile Court

Have you prepared a written supervision plan describing how you will prevent reoffending?
Do you understand which of the ten protective disposition types may realistically apply?
Have you confirmed the hearing date and whether your child's attendance is mandatory?

4️⃣ If the Case Moves Toward Criminal Prosecution

Have you discussed with counsel whether requesting a transfer back to juvenile court is viable?
Do you understand how a criminal record versus a protective disposition record differs for your child's future (school, employment, visa applications)?
Have you gathered all documents relevant to sentencing mitigation, such as age, remorse, and family circumstances?

Frequently Asked Questions

Q. My child is 12 years old — can they be criminally punished?

A. No. Children aged 10 to 13 are considered pre-criminal juveniles (촉법소년) and cannot be criminally punished because they lack criminal responsibility under Korean law (형법 제9조, 소년법 제4조 제1항 제2호). They can, however, still receive a protective disposition such as probation or a counseling order through juvenile court.

Q. What is the difference between a protective disposition and a criminal conviction?

A. A protective disposition is issued by juvenile court under the Juvenile Act and is not treated as a criminal punishment, so it generally does not create a criminal conviction record (소년법 제32조). A criminal conviction, by contrast, comes from a criminal court and can appear on certain background checks depending on the sentence.

Q. Can my child avoid having any record at all?

A. If the prosecutor grants conditional non-prosecution after the juvenile completes counseling, education, or community service conditions, the case is closed without indictment, meaning no conviction and no court proceeding occurs (소년법 제49조의3-related prosecutorial discretion). This is generally the most favorable realistic outcome for first-time, lower-severity cases.

Q. Is it too late to ask for non-prosecution once the case has been referred to juvenile court?

A. Conditional non-prosecution specifically is a prosecutor-stage decision, so once the case is referred to juvenile court, that particular route is closed for the current charge. However, juvenile court can still choose a lenient protective disposition, and in some situations a criminal court can transfer a case back to juvenile court under 소년법 제50조.

Q. Do I, as a parent, need to attend every hearing?

A. Guardians are generally expected to attend police and court proceedings involving their child and may be asked to submit or testify about a supervision plan. Courts often view parental engagement as a relevant factor in choosing among the range of protective dispositions available under 소년법 제32조.

Q. Will my child's juvenile record follow them into adulthood?

A. Protective disposition records are treated differently from adult criminal records and are generally not disclosed in the same way, though the specific handling depends on the type of disposition and subsequent legal developments. It's important to discuss with counsel how a particular disposition may or may not affect future background checks, employment, or visa applications.

Q. What happens if my child has a prior protective disposition and reoffends?

A. A prior record can influence the severity of the next disposition or increase the likelihood of prosecution rather than diversion, since courts and prosecutors consider prior history when assessing risk and choosing an appropriate measure. This makes early, careful handling of a first offense particularly important.

Q. Can the victim's family affect the outcome?

A. Yes. Evidence of restitution, a sincere apology, or reconciliation with the victim is frequently one of the most influential factors in a prosecutor's decision to grant conditional non-prosecution or in a court's choice of a lighter protective disposition.

Q. Should I hire a lawyer even if the police say it's a minor case?

A. Many parents are told informally that a case is 'minor' and decide not to seek counsel, but the classification of severity and the resulting track (protective disposition, prosecution, or diversion) is ultimately decided by the prosecutor or court, not by the police at the initial stage. Early legal input can affect which materials are submitted before that decision is made.

Q. What is the role of a 'local juvenile crime lawyer' in these cases?

A. A local juvenile crime lawyer familiar with the specific police station, prosecutor's office, or family court handling your child's case can advise on regional practice tendencies, accompany the juvenile to interviews, and help prepare submissions tailored to that office's typical approach to diversion and disposition.

Official References

개인정보처리방침

법무법인 프런티어(이하 “사무소”)는 개인정보보호법에 따라 정보주체의 개인정보 및 권익을 보호하고 개인정보와 관련된 정보주체의 고충을 신속하고 원활하게 처리하기 위하여 본 개인정보 처리방침을 수립·공개합니다.

제 1 조 수집하는 개인정보의 항목, 목적, 방법
제 2 조 개인정보의 처리 및 보유기간
제 3 조 개인정보의 제3자 제공
제 4 조 개인정보 처리업무의 위탁
제 5 조 정보주체의 권리·의무 및 그 행사방법
제 6 조 개인정보의 파기
제 7 조 의견수렴 및 불만처리
제 8 조 개인정보 처리방침의 변경
제 9 조 개인정보의 안전성 확보 조치

제 1 조 (수집하는 개인정보의 항목, 목적, 방법)
① 게시판 글 작성 시 필수 항목에 대한 수집목적은 ‘별도의 구체적 상담을 위하여’이며 수집항목은 ‘이름, 이메일, 연락처’입니다.
② 전항 외에 고객의 서비스 이용 과정이나 요청 사항 처리 과정에서 ‘IP주소, 접속로그, 단말기 및 환경정보, 서비스 이용기록, 쿠키’와 같은 정보들이 자동으로 수집 및 저장될 수 있으며, 이 때의 수집목적은 ‘사용자 홈페이지 이용, 사이트 이용에 대한 문의 민원 등 고객 고충 처리’입니다.
③ 사무소는 ‘홈페이지 고객 문의/고충 처리 시 전화 또는 인터넷을 통한 상담’과 같은 방법으로 개인정보를 수집합니다

제 2 조 (개인정보의 처리 및 보유기간)
관계법령의 규정에 따라 개인정보를 보존하여야 하는 의무가 있는 경우가 아닌 한, 정보주체의 개인정보는 원칙적으로 해당 개인정보의 처리목적이 달성될 때까지 보유 및 이용되며, 그 목적이 달성되면 지체 없이 파기됩니다.

제 3 조 (개인정보의 제3자 제공)
사무소는 정보주체의 개인정보를 본 처리방침에서 명시한 목적에 한해서만 처리하며 정보주체의 사전동의가 있는 경우 또는 개인정보보호법 등 관계법령의 규정에 의거한 경우에만 개인정보를 제3자에게 제공합니다. 사무소는 현재 개인정보를 제3자에게 제공하지 않고 있습니다.

제 4 조 (개인정보 처리업무의 위탁)
사무소는 현재 귀하의 개인정보 보호를 위해 귀하의 개인정보를 직접 취급 관리하고 있습니다. 단, 향후 보다 전문적인 서비스를 제공하기 위하여 제3의 전문기관에 귀하의 정보를 위탁할 필요가 있다고 판단되는 경우, 귀하의 사전 동의 하에 개인정보에 대한 취급을 위탁할 수 있습니다.

제 5 조 (정보주체의 권리·의무 및 그 행사방법)
① 정보주체는 개인정보보호법 등 관계법령이 정하는 바에 따라 사무소에 대해 개인정보의 열람, 정정 및 삭제, 처리정지 요구 등 개인정보 보호 관련 권리를 행사할 수 있습니다.
② 제1항에 따른 권리행사는 정보주체의 법정대리인이나 위임을 받은 사람을 통해서도 할 수 있습니다. 다만, 이 경우에는 개인정보보호법 시행규칙에 따른 위임장을 사무소에 제출하여야 합니다.
③ 사무소는 정보주체의 권리행사에 대하여 개인정보보호법 등 관계법령이 정하는 바에 따라 지체 없이 조치하겠습니다.

제 6 조 (개인정보의 파기)
① 사무소는 원칙적으로 개인정보의 처리목적이 달성된 경우 등 그 개인정보가 불필요하게 되었을 때에는 지체 없이 해당 개인정보를 파기합니다.
② 사무소가 관계법령의 규정에 따라 개인정보를 파기하지 아니하고 보존하여야 하는 경우에는 해당 개인정보 또는 개인정보파일을 다른 개인정보와 분리해서 저장·관리 합니다.
③ 사무소는 파기사유가 발생한 개인정보를 선정하여 개인정보 보호책임자의 승인을 받아 해당 개인정보를 파기합니다.
④ 사무소는 파기하여야 할 개인정보가 전자적 파일 형태인 경우 복원이 불가능한 방법으로 영구 삭제하며, 이외의 기록물, 인쇄물, 서면, 그 밖의 기록매체인 경우 파쇄 또는 소각합니다.

제 7 조 (의견수렴 및 불만처리)
정보주체는 개인정보 보호 관련 문의, 불만처리, 피해구제 등에 관한 사항을 아래 개인정보 보호책임자 또는 담당부서에 문의하실 수 있습니다. 사무소는 정보주체의 문의에 대하여 신속하고 충분한 답변을 드릴 것입니다.

개인정보 보호 책임자 : 변호사
연락처 : 02.

제 8 조 (개인정보 처리방침의 변경)
사무소의 개인정보 처리방침은 관련 법령, 지침 및 사무소 내부규정에 따라 변경될 수 있으며, 개인정보 처리방침이 변경되는 경우 관련 법령이 정하는 방법에 따라 공개합니다.

제 9 조 (개인정보의 안전성 확보 조치)
사무소는 개인정보의 안전성 확보를 위해 다음과 같은 조치를 취하고 있습니다.
관리적 조치 : 내부관리계획의 수립 및 시행, 구성원에 대한 정기적인 개인정보 보호교육 등
기술적 조치 : 개인정보처리시스템 등의 접근권한 관리, 접근통제시스템 설치, 고유식별정보 등의 암호화, 보안프로그램의 설치 등
물리적 조치 : 전산실, 자료보관실 등 개인정보 보관장소에 대한 접근통제